i can only speak for watching it on a pc, but i didn't see any difference in
video quality with this release (xvid codec, bsplayer). as for the one or two
glitches, they're so incredibly minor (nothing is even missed) that they're not
even worth mentioning. and it was never out of sync. whoever's been suitcase-
nuking this thing all night on orlydb was either high or has something against
the poor people in europe and elsewhere who are staying up to the wee hours
trying to watch this thing.
[#26659]
Written by: nothlit1 [04/04/2007, 23:24]
Quote by frog1234
ugh, it's bad.
when they move i see grey, the colour is a frame behind the luminance.
anyone else notice this?
yes, i absolutely noticed this, especially on abrupt scene changes or fast
motion. while this release is certainly watchable, it's nowhere near the
quality of previous releases.
[#26661]
Written by: M.a.x [04/04/2007, 23:53]
big thx from poland.
someone are watched this version on stand-alone dvd player? becaus that version
have nuke and i this is scary. =o
[#26663]
Written by: SaveMeJeebus [05/04/2007, 00:03]
stop your freakin whining! this 350mb version is fine. 1 or 2 glitches, but
thats nothing.
10/10
thanks eztv
[#26664]
Written by: rseiler [05/04/2007, 00:07]
i suspect people are seeing vastly different things due to using fundamentally
different methods of playback such as ffdshow vs xvid vs divx vs all-in-one
players like vlc, etc.
[#26666]
Written by: DungeonRaider [05/04/2007, 00:09]
i can live with a few glitches.. in fact i've put up with worse than this encode.
if it was a show i don't plan to get the dvds of eventually i might be a little
more discerning but lost is a given that i'll buy :-/
[#26669]
Written by: thebishop74 [05/04/2007, 00:15]
when people are saying it's nuked, it's nuked, end of story, wait for proper or
download the hr if it's better.
you always get people coming in and claiming crap like "it's only really
minor", or "it's still very/100% watchable", ignore 'all' those posts, they are
usually guys who don't have a clue, and/or are willing to put up with stuff
that would annoy the crap out of most people.
or even worse, they are idiots who preview like 30 seconds of the file and
claim it's not nuked based on that...
i have never found a nuked file that was even remotely watchable, usually even
the nuked description is just the tip of the iceberg, just reads the posts,
talk of it being a doggy rip from a bad source, general poor quality, and most
of that combined will also usually give really bad results on many stand alone
players.
don't keep nuked releases alive, just let them just die, it's embarrassing to
see 20000 people trying to download a nuked release.
and it sure was nice to see 11 people thank the scene for a nuked release on
the first page, even better that it almost meant no nuke warning on that first
page, thanks to rseiler for getting in there fast...
[#26671]
Written by: hetzinha [05/04/2007, 00:42]
hey guys! everything is working great to me! the quality is perfect and also
the speed. i got it less than one hour!!
thanks very much for the up!!!
hetzinha fm brazil.
[#26672]
Written by: frog1234 [05/04/2007, 00:43]
there is a typo in the name, it should read sorry not sorny
[#26673]
Written by: hal9000 [05/04/2007, 00:43]
the abc feed to the canadian station had glitches that's why it was unnuked.
lets see if the actual abc feed was glitched. if so there will be no proper.
[#26676]
Written by: Beetman [05/04/2007, 01:03]
any idea when we can expect a proper from the american feed?
[#26677]
Written by: DungeonRaider [05/04/2007, 01:12]
Quote by thebishop74
when people are saying it's nuked, it's nuked, end of story,
wait for proper or download the hr if it's better.
the problem with that theory is that nuking can be done by anyone with access to
the pre database and sometimes for reasons other than the quality of the
actually encode... it could be related to the size of the rar files (which
doesn't matter to those who distribute the avi), it could be typo in the
filename, it could be related to the size of the encode (10mb either way won't
make a huge difference to the quality but is enough according to scene rules) or
it could be related to the sample that's included in the rar files (again,
doesn't matter to avi distribution). some release can be nuked for some reason
and then un-nuked because the reason isn't valid. as shown in this thread this
encode has been nuked and unnuked several times. there have even be a few fake
nukes by people causing trouble.. similar to the fake releases that are
sometimes pre'd.
so to say it's the end of the story is very naive and short sighted. so long as
people are downloading with their eyes open and are willing to risk having to
download a file again rather than waiting for a proper that may never come or
may take several more hours - who's to say they aren't allowed to take that risk.
[#26678]
Written by: taddict01 [05/04/2007, 01:15]
i just watched it, it works fine
[#26679]
Written by: VScommo [05/04/2007, 01:30]
Quote by thebishop74
when people are saying it's nuked, it's nuked, end of story,
wait for proper or
download the hr if it's better.
you always get people coming in and claiming crap like "it's only really
minor", or "it's still very/100% watchable", ignore 'all' those posts, they are
usually guys who don't have a clue, and/or are willing to put up with stuff
that would annoy the crap out of most people.
or even worse, they are idiots who preview like 30 seconds of the file and
claim it's not nuked based on that...
i have never found a nuked file that was even remotely watchable, usually even
the nuked description is just the tip of the iceberg, just reads the posts,
talk of it being a doggy rip from a bad source, general poor quality, and most
of that combined will also usually give really bad results on many stand alone
players.
don't keep nuked releases alive, just let them just die, it's embarrassing to
see 20000 people trying to download a nuked release.
and it sure was nice to see 11 people thank the scene for a nuked release on
the first page, even better that it almost meant no nuke warning on that first
page, thanks to rseiler for getting in there fast...
sorry mate, but you are a moron.
dungeonraider you're 100% correct with what you said
oh, and lost.s03e15.left.behind.proper.hdtv.xvid-fqm just pred
[#26680]
Written by: thebishop74 [05/04/2007, 01:41]
Quote by dungeonraider
so to say it's the end of the story is very naive and
short sighted. so long as people are downloading with their eyes open and are
willing to risk having to download a file again rather than waiting for a
proper that may never come or may take several more hours - who's to say they
aren't allowed to take that risk.
yes, people are free to take the risk, but it does not change the nuked status,
which makes it a poor risk 99.9% of the time, very few people even pay
attention to nukes for file length etc, your playing up an angle that barely
even shows it's head anymore.
as for the nuked and un-nuked, that happens a fair bit, but it's usually a sign
the file is not great, meaning even if it stays un-nuked, chances are many
people are not going to be happy with the rip.
if a file is being declared nuked for whatever reason, your a lot better off
waiting to see if a proper shows up, it's not going to kill you to wait, and
more traffic on the nuked file just means less for the proper later on, because
people don't like having to download something twice.
i'd like to see more people hold off, far to often 'everyone' goes for the
nuke, and then the proper takes forever to download...
