Supernatural Could End in 2010, But Should It?

should supernatural end. wow that's a question now isn't it? i just re-watched the finale of season
4 wondering that same thing. my answer: i don't know. and here's why i say that. for the first three
seasons of this television series, we have seen many things that were very predictable. it's like we
knew what was coming in the first ten minutes of the show. but the fourth season really changed
that. i have to say, the end result where you find out ruby's plot was absolutely phenomenal. i had
no idea that's how it would happen. looking back at what happened makes me wonder if there should be
a sixth season or not. if it ended at five, then i can tell it would be a great ending, but
honestly, fighting lucifer is saying a whole lot. hell on earth is saying a whole lot. joss whedon
didn't even go there with angel. he let that carry on into his comic series, as we saw in that awful
cliff hanger in the finale. it seems like it would take more than one season to tell that kind of
story, although with kripke's writing and mcg's production, i wouldn't doubt they could pull it off.
but lets say it happens this way. sam ends up on lucifer's side in the end and dean ends up on
god's. kind of makes for a lame sixth season idea. it would probably end up them trying to get back
to one another and basically make the whole fifth season pointless. lets say they stick together and
they beat lucifer. what more can they really do? i mean they defeated the devil for crying out loud?
i say lets see where kripke goes with this one. it has the potential to drag on, but i'd give it a
few episodes to judge and see how it unfolds.

i'm just gonna say it short. what else can you do once you've defeated the devil? answer; nothing,
you can relax and revel in the fact that you've stopped the apocalypse.

well season 5 should be the last because......who am i kidding, my wife and i would watch supernatural
well past hell freezing over!.the chemistry is great and i'm sure someone can come up with something
to keep it fresh for a season or 2 yet.heres hoping!

i totally agree with sheshy ...

for a show that revolves around defeating demons, bad-ass spirits, vampires and all the bad in the
world, defeating the apocalypse itself is the ultimate goal ... there simply is nothing to put on
top of that (in the world of mystery shows).

leave saving planet earth from bad-ass aliens to the doctor, the various upcoming stargate
adventures and james t. kirk ... supernatural has a very clear scope with a very clear ending in sight.

by the way ... what should the winchesters do after defeating lucifer? getting bored in heaven on earth?

in my opinion supernatural is one of the best shows right now possibly the best, and why is that,
well i believe it's because they know where they're going with it, the plan for the show is for it
to end, now i know people say now that they want it to continue and everything but if it continues
for the sake of money and not for the sake of the show being all it can be, well it would become a
bad show and people would then wish it had ended right were it should had, personally i would watch
it until the actual apocalypse, but it's for the best if we just let it go as it should.

as long as the cast do not get tired of playing the roles it should go as long as it can. seriously,
all this talk about good shows ending big. evidently most of you forget that the really great shows
too often end because of producers or actors bailing out on the fans. i am not talking about those
shows that have no more stories to tell, i am talking about the ones that should go for as long as
the actors, directors and writers have no problems continuing.

when no one has any more ideas for such a show or the main actors no longer want to play the roles,
then a satisfying ending should be discussed. but don't treat your fans with disrespect, be upfront
about this stuff and they will understand. most fans know that a show would not be the same if
something like one of the main actors decided to be killed off or something like that.

i say keep it up until those involved are thinking of mutiny. some great shows end way before they
get old, and that just plain sucks.

keep it going there is always some sort evil they fight.

i had made my peace with season 5 being the last, but the idea of it continuing makes me feel happy
- so longs as the quality is on the level of season 4.

i could see them going the dark route of sam and deans mother being a demon if it goes on, as we've
been told previously that demons were once human. could make for interesting tv and would probably
be the only way to create an arc that means as much to viewers as the satan battle.

this should have already stopped after the third season... i mean katie cassidy was gone in season 4 : (

i don't know man, i think it should end
or maybe change the view, don't know, maybe see things on the perspective of john.
what i ask myself is, okay, there is hell right on they ass, but what about heaven? far as i know the
angels, basically, wanted the same thing that the demons, and nether deans or sam, or bob, or cas,
and all those wanted heaven on earth or hell on earth...
then if they decided to make some sort of storie about dean and sam putting heaven, well, back on
heaven, it would be a good storie.
cheers

i think supernatural should end with season 5. it will make for a great final chapter of an awesome
ride ever since the pilot debuted. i mean, what the hell is left(literally) after beating lucifer

yeah, beating lucifer! nobody said anything about killing him.

i love this show but after the angel and demon story i donot think i can go back to watch normal
episode again

the fact is, lucifer is not defeated, but rejailed, and for a thoussand years angels are supposed to rule,
but they would need a lot of help..not everything is going to be sweet and nice...

you didnt have to watch.